Caleb married Abigail Goodsell (45816) , daughter of Thomas Goodsell (ca 1646-16 May 1713) & Sarah Hemingway (26850) (26 Jul 1663-18 Mar 1725). Born 28 Feb 1699[/1700] in New Haven, CT.56 Abigail died in East Haven, CT on 12 Jan 1761.55 Buried in Old Graveyard, East Haven.