12 Jan 1726/7 Ichabod first married Mary Bowen, daughter of Joseph Bowen & Elizabeth Round, in Rehoboth, MA. Born on 1 Jul 1706 in Rehoboth, MA. Mary died bef Nov 1748.

On 19 Nov 1748 when Ichabod was 42, he second married Bethiah Wood in Warren, RI. Born on 17 Nov 1718 in Swansea, Bristol County, Massachusetts.