On 31 May 1727 when Mehitable was 24, she married Benjamin Neale, son of Benjamin Neale (7 Jan 1668/9-12 Jan 1746) & Lydia Payne (20 Jul 1670-), in Braintree, MA. Born on 31 Mar 1694 in Braintree, MA. Benjamin died in Quincy, MA, on 5 Dec 1747; he was 53. Buried in Hancock Cemetery, Quincy.

Benjamin, son of Benjamin & Lydia (Payne) Neale.