Pane-Joyce Genealogy

Family of Sabra Wade (31489) & Bradley Cutler

36124. Phebe Cutler. Born ca 1796 in Providence, RI. Phebe died on 11 Aug 1856 in Fairfield, Huron Co., OH.

Phebe first married Nicholas Richardson.

Child:

37513

Seth Matteson Richardson (8 Aug 1818-13 Apr 1919)

On 3 Jan 1822 Phebe second married Francis Rogers in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY. Born ca 1799 in New York. Francis died on 30 Nov 1879 in North Fairfield, Huron Co., OH.

Their children include:

37514	i.	Sabra C. Rogers (5 Feb 1823-16 Jan 1851)
37515	ii.	Bradley F. Rogers (5 Nov 1824-)
37516	iii.	Maranda Rose Rogers (6 Sep 1826-)
37517	iv.	David R. Rogers (31 Aug 1828-)
37518	v.	Otis N. Rogers (15 Aug 1833-)
37519	vi.	William Henry Rogers (3 Mar 1841-)

36125. Otis Cutler. Born on 15 May 1798 in Otsego, Herkimer Co., NY. Otis died on 6 Feb 1881; he was 82.

Otis married Charlotte [Cutler].

36126. Nathan Wade Cutler. Born on 1 Mar 1800 in Otsego, Herkimer Co., NY. Nathan Wade died in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY, on 8 Jul 1875; he was 75. Buried in Atwater Cemetery, Sempronius.

From the Book of biographies: this volume contains biographical sketches of leading citizens of Cortland County, N.Y. Buffalo, N.Y.: Biographical Pub. Co., 1898, page 496:
“Dwight K. Cutler, one of the most porminent and wealthy residents of this county, residing in the town of Scoot, where he is engaged in general farmin, and in operating a first class scientific dairy, is a son of Nathan W. and Ruth (Whiting) Cutler, and was born in Sempronius, Cayuga County, N. Y., April 27, 1835.
“Bradley Cutler, the grandfather, ...
“Nathan W. Cutler, the father, was born in Herkimer County, N., Y., March 1, 1800, and married Ruth Whiting, who was born October 12, 1804. She was a daughter of Dr. Jeremiah B. Whiting, who attended academy and then graduated from a medical college and became quite a successful practitioner. He was classed among the best physicians in his part of the state, and his practice extended over Cayuga, Onondaga and Cortland Counties for a period of thirty or forty years. He finally moved to the State of Michigan where he died. Nathan W. Cutler was a boy yet in his ’teans when the family came to Sempronius, and there he lived all his life, dying in 1875, his wife having been called to her Heavenly Home the year previous. He was an honored and reputable citizen of his town, who spent his time in cultivating the home place. In politics he was a Republican and filled nearly all the town offices, being assessor and justice of the peace for years. He was a deacon of the Baptist Church, founded by his father, for a long time. He was always active in church work and filled all the offices, recognizing no labor too arduous when the welfare of the church was concerned. It was zeal such as this that contributed largely to the success of that denomination. He left a family of three sons and three daughters, as follows: Myron D., who died in 1892; Charles, a farmer of Ira Station, Cayuga County; Jane A., the wife of James W. Clark, a farmer of Scott; Dwight K.; Cynthia M., deceased, wife of Volney Hawke, who ded in the army—she then married Jefferson Tinker; Thalia F., who married Dorr Smith, a resident of Sempronius.”

Nathan Wade married Ruth Whiting, daughter of Dr. Jeremiah B. Whiting. Born on 12 Oct 1804 in Scott, Washington Co., NY. Ruth died in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY, on 7 May 1874; she was 69. Buried in Atwater Cemetery, Sempronius.

Their children include:

37520	i.	Myron D. Cutler (ca 1826-)
37521	ii.	Charles W. Cutler (ca 1828-)
37522	iii.	Jane A. Cutler (ca 1832-)
37523	iv.	Dwight Cutler (21 Apr 1835-16 Jul 1917)
37524	v.	Cynthia M. Cutler (12 Aug 1838-)
37525	vi.	Julia F. Cutler (ca 1841-)

36127. Bradley Cutler. Born on 14 Dec 1801 in Otsego, Herkimer Co., NY. Bradley died in 1893 in Monmouth, Warren Co., IL. Buried in East Winfield Cemetery, Herkimer Co.

Bradley married Thankful Spencer. Born ca 1807 in New York. Thankful died in 1864. Buried in East Winfield Cemetery, Herkimer Co.

Their children include:

37526	i.	Judsen Cutler (ca 1831-5 Mar 1873)
37527	ii.	George W. Cutler (ca 1833-)
37528	iii.	Sarah Lois Cutler (ca 1844-)

36128. Penelope Cutler. Born on 30 Sep 1804 in Otsego, Herkimer Co., NY. Penelope died on 4 Aug 1876; she was 71.

ATWATER CEMETERY was later known as Reynolds Cemetery and Skilton has "Sempronius Cemetery - not far from the Church"

Located in the NW corner of Lot No. 89, 3/4 mile from Sempronius hamlet and church, on south side of Frazier Road, as shown on page 65, New Century Atlas of Cayuga Co., NY. Copied 1959 by Leslie Luther, Moravia, NY.

Atwater or Sempronius Cemtery Records http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem186.htm “This cemetery is horribly overgrown, the back part almost impassable with bushes and briars. Here again I found stones down so long they were entirely covered with a mat of myrtle, which went unnoticed unless you just happened to walk there and feel a firmness underfoot.

The Skilton records contained 27 names, L. Luther has 44, and I found 52. By doing this composite list of these three, we have about 80 names. And I am sure there must still be some we didn't happen to walk on. Copied 1962 by Mabel Crosby, Moravia, RD #1
This cemetery has the following Cutlers:
Cutler, Bradley d. May 12, 1863 ae 87y
Cutler, Sabra his wife d. Sep.17, 1863 ae 90y
Cutler, Nathan d. Jul.8, 1875 ae 75y
Cutler, Ruth Whiting, w of Nathan d. May 7, 1874 ae
Cutler, Alvira w of Myron D. Cutler d. Oct.25, 1854 ae 29-5-1

Sand Hill Cemetery, Town of Sempronius, Located 8 1/2 miles north of Dresserville, on west side of road toward Kelloggsville. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem185.htmCopied 1955 by Leslie L. Luther. This cemetery has these Cutlers:

Cutler, Charles W. b. Jan. 21, 1828 d. Aug. 16, 1900
Sarah M., his wife b. June 12, 1830 d. Apr. 23, 1897
Elmer b. Jan. 6, 1870 d. Apr. 11, 1910
Cutler, William 1863-1927
Cutler, Hattie M. 1851-1936

INDIAN MOUND CEMETERY, Moravia, New York, Transcribed by Steve and Pat McKay
CUTLER, http://members.aol.com/gendata54/imound.html#CHenry, b Aug. 27, 1792 d Mar. 18, 1866. This cemetery has the following Cutlers and related families:
CUTLER, Henry, b Aug. 27, 1792 d Mar. 18, 1866
Mercy BISHOP his wife, b Apr. 5, 1796 d Mar. 31, 1854
M. A., ____ - ____
McClean, Susan, b Mar. 12, 179(3?) d Sept. 30, 1835
CUTLER, Henry, 1822 - 1899
Emily McClean, 1829 - 1913
Willard, 1848 - 1934
Jennie VAN ETTEN, 1849 - 1929
MINER, Charles T., 1876 - 1943
Alice CUTLER, 1874 - 1946
Cutler, Rhoda M., dau of John & Wealthy d. Mar. 29, 1876 ae 58y 10mo
Cutler, "Little Johnny" d. ae 14months
Smith, Dorr 1840-1916
Thalia F. Cutler, his wife 1841-1916
CHRUCH, Byron, 1841 - 1900, (F. & A.M. emblem), "Father"
Carrie K. his wife, 1844-1929, "Mother"
William R. their son, 1870 - 1900, "Will"
CUTLER, Fay, 1857 - 1931, "Fay"
Anna M. his wife, 1858 - 1929, "Anna"
Infant son, -1899-
MELLEN, Jeremiah d Oct. 21, 1881 ae 78 yrs, "Father"
"An honest man, God's noblest work."The tribute of a Son.
Fanny wife of J. MELLEN d Aug. 7, 1877 ae 73 yrs, "Mother"
Adelphia wife of Allen PORTER, 1836 - 1870, "Adelphia"
Melita wife of James B. HUNTER, d July 22, 1871 ae 28 yrs, "Melita"
J. Knowlton, 1838 - 1912, "Knowlton"
Proctor, d in Hampton Hospital, Fortress Monroe, d June 22, 1865 ae 24 yrs, "Proctor"
"Our Alice" went home Dec. 22, 1861 ae 16 yrs, "Alice"
Dwight d Oct. 27, 1856 ae 30 yrs, "Our first born and God's"
CUTLER, Janette MELLEN, d July 17, 1865 ae 34 yrs
(Note: In 1955, a headstone was found near the tool house face down with inscription:
"Janet, wife of J.L. CUTLER, M.D., died July 17, 1865 ae 34y 8mo, 26da")
Also on this lot a headstone: "Martha" and a large iron dog

Kelloggsville Cemetery, Town of Sempronius. This cemetery is located in the NW corner of Lot 47, town of Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY, a short distance S of Kelloggsville hamlet, on the W side of the road to Dresserville, as indicated on the map of Niles township, New Century Atlas of Cay. Co., NY, 1904. Copied by L. Luther - 1959. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem189.htm
The Kelloggsville Cemetery has these Cutlers:
Cutler, Frank H. 1855-1917
Carrie H., his w 1860-1948
D. K. 1882-1940
Jennie M., his wife 1883-1972
M. Aleeta 1917-1919
Margaret C. Lieber 1908-1951

A History & Profile of the Town of Mentz, Village of Port Byron & Hamlet of Centerport
Cayuga County, New York As contained in the book: History of Cayuga County, New York 1789-1879; By Elliot G. Storke, Chapter XXXVII. “The successive presidents are Elmore P. Ross, 1838; Samuel Harnden, 1839, `42 and `43; Cyrus C. Peas, 1840 and `41; James CUTLER, 1844, `45 and `47-`51 . . . “

God’s Acre Cemetery, South Seneca ST., Weedsport, N.Y. NOTE: Names marked with an asterick (*) are from a list made by Raymond B. Traver in 1916 but which could not be authenticated. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem24.htm. It lists only:
CUTLER, William *, d. 1848

TOWN OF MORAVIA MORAVIA RURAL or DRY CREEK CEMETERY
Located on the southern edge of the Village of Moravia, Route 38, back in on the east side of the road. Copied by Leslie L. Luther, Moravia, NY. It lists:
CUTLER Alice d. Mar. 31, 1854 b. July 21, 1830
dau. of H. & E.A.
Edward d. Sept. 22, 1852 b. Apr. 27, 1832
son of H. & E.A.

Complete Name Index to The History of Cayuga County 1789-1879 book by Elliot Storke index by Leslie Luther transcription by Elaine Hutson http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/storke/a.html
Lists the following:
CUTLER A. H. 446
Bradley 483
Charles 481
Henry 77, 459, 461, 474

On 27 Jan 1822 when Penelope was 17, she married Joshua Rathbone (36679) , son of Rev. Daniel Rathbone (32819) (11 Apr 1754-30 Mar 1806) & Sabra Holman (9 May 1771-), in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY. Born on 19 May 1801 in Sempronius, NY on a Tuesday afternoon. Joshua died in Oct 1885 in St. Johns, MI (Son Daniel B.s Home). Occupation: Carpenter.⁴⁴⁸

Cayuga County, New York Guarianships, listed on SAMPUBCO http://www.sampubco.com/guard/ny/nycayuga03.htm
Minor’s name Deceased Parent Petitioner Deceased Res. Vol. Page#
RATHBUN, JOSHUA RATHBUN, DANIEL Rathbone, Anna SEMPRONIUS 6-A-159
RATHBUN, JOSHUA RATHBUN, DANIEL RATHBUN, DIAS SEMPRONIUS 6-A-104
RATHBUN, JOSHUA RATHBUN, DANIEL RATHBUN, SABRA SEMPRONIUS 6-A-34

THE RATHBONE GENEALOGY, by Cooley, states:
“JOSHUA RATHBONE ( Daniel, Valentine, Joshua, John, John, John, Richard), born May 19, 1801; married Penelope Cutler, January 27, 1822. He died October, 1885, at the home of his son Daniel B., in St. John’s Mich. The children, except Mary and Sabra were born in Fairfield, Huron Co., Ohio. Sabra and Mary were born in Sempronius (now Niles) Cayuga Co., N. Y. Children:

1. Sabra Cordia, b. Mar. 1, 1823; m. Amasa C. Allen, July 4, 1840; they had 4 children:
i. Alonzo D., m. Laura Purdy; one son, Walter.
ii. Merwin
iii. Lillia, d. a young woman
iv. Lola; m. William Van Vate

2. Nancy A., b. Nov. 20, 1827; m. Samuel W. Parker, 1842.

3. Mary J. b. June 2, 1829; m. ---

4. Harriet L. b. Nov. 4, 1831; m. John Vangrison, Nov. 8, 1849.

5. Maryette, b. Nov. 29, 1833; m. George Mintony; he d. July 30, 1861.

6. Daniel B., b. Jan. 3, 1836; m. Louisa Hall, Oct. 6, 1857.

7. William Henry, b. April 1, 1840; d. June 4, 1842.

8. Charlotte A., B, Feb. 19, 1844; m. freeman Strunk, May 3, 1865.

9. Phoebe A., b. May 7, 1838; d. Ded. 16, 1840.

10. Adelaide C., b. --; m. Freeman Strunk.”

Their children include:

37529	i.	Sabra Cordella Rathbone (1 Mar 1823-)
37530	ii.	(infant) Rathbone (Died soon) (20 Feb 1825-20 Mar 1825)
37531	iii.	Nancy A. Rathbone (30 Nov 1827-)
37532	iv.	Mary J. Rathbone (Died soon) (2 Jun 1829-29 Apr 1830)
37533	v.	Harriet Lorinda Rathbone (4 Nov 1831-2 Feb 1901)
37534	vi.	Maryette Rathbone (29 Nov 1833-20 Jul 1861)
37535	vii.	Daniel B. Rathbone (3 Jan 1836-)
37536	viii.	Phebe Ann Rathbone (Died soon) (7 May 1838-16 Dec 1840)
37537	ix.	William Henry Rathbone (Died soon) (1 Apr 1840-4 Jun 1842)
37538	x.	Charlotte A. Rathbone (19 Feb 1844-)
37539	xi.	Adelaide C. Rathbone

36129. Charles Cutler. Born on 3 Mar 1807 in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY. Charles died on 14 Sep 1875; he was 68. Buried in Clear Lake Cemetery, Cerro Gordo, IA.

Charles married Rebecca [Cutler]. Born ca 1822 in New York.

Their children include:

37540	i.	Charles J. Cutler (ca 1840-)
37541	ii.	Phebe J. Cutler (ca 1842-)
37542	iii.	Charlotte Cutler (ca 1845-)
37543	iv.	Mary Cutler (ca 1849-)

36130. Demas Cutler. Born on 23 Jan 1810. Demas died in Nora Springs, Floyd Co., IA, on 9 Oct 1890; he was 80. Buried in Rock Grove Cemetery, Nora Springs.

Demas married Cyntha [Cutler]. Born ca 1820 in Pennsylvania.

Their children include:

37544	i.	Mortimer Cutler (ca 1839-)
37545	ii.	Corydon E. Cutler (ca 1847-)
37546	iii.	Julius Cutler (ca 1850-)
37547	iv.	Vernon Cutler (ca 1863-)

36131. Almond H. Cutler. Born on 20 Nov 1812. Almond H. died in Niles, Cayuga Co., NY, on 20 Mar 1902; he was 89. Buried in New Hope Cemetery, Niles.

Almond H. married Sarah [Cutler]. Born ca 1820 in New York.

Their children include:

	37548	i.	Byron A. Cutler (ca 1842-)
	37549	ii.	Cornelin E. Cutler (ca 1848-)

36132. Austin Cutler. Born on 10 Apr 1815 in Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY. Austin died in 1874.

Austin married Rhoda Mather.

Their children include:

37550	i.	Helen A. Cutler (ca 1838-)
37551	ii.	Sabra Cutler (ca 1841-)
37552	iii.	Wealthy Cutler
37553	iv.	John Cutler
37554	v.	Lois Cutler

Previous · Next

Contents · Index · Surnames · Contact

D. Pane-Joyce
http://aleph0.clarku.edu/~djoyce/gen/report/
Created Mar 2008 with the reluctant help of Reunion,
from Leister Productions, Inc.