On 14 Jan 1749 Sarah first married Benjamin Cook (24649) , son of John Cook (9548) (ca 1685-16 Aug 1761) & Abigail Johnson (1 Nov 1687-2 Dec 1768), in Wallingford, CT. Born on 22 Jan 1725 in Wallingford, CT. Benjamin died on 28 Oct 1758; he was 33.

On 18 Oct 1760 Sarah second married John Winston, son of Daniel Winston (18 Aug 1690-17 Jan 1780) & Abigail Hotchkiss (12 Oct 1695-30 Aug 1735), in Wallingford, CT. Born on 7 Apr 1726 in Wallingford, CT. John died in East Haven, CT ca 1789.