On 30 May 1737 when Ichabod was 24, he married Sarah Winslow in Freetown, MA.

Children of Ichabod and Sarah (Winslow) Eddy:
    i. Betsey Eddy, b. 1 Sep 1737 at Swansea;
    ii. Huldah Eddy, b. 23 Aug 1739 at Swansea, m. Henry Brightman Jr;
    iii. Henry Eddy, b. 8 Nov 1741 at Swansea, m. Ruth Gifford;
    iv. David Eddy, b. 17 Dec 1743 at Swansea,m. Cynthia Cook;
    v. Zephaniah Eddy, b. 17 Nov 1745 at Westport, m. Anna Wood;
    vi. Rhoba Eddy; b. 29 Oct 1751 at Westport, m. Abraham Anthony 13 Jan 1774;
    vii. Ebenezer Eddy, b. 30 Aug 1753, m. Rachel Sherman;
    viii. Bethany Eddy, b. 29 Jan 1755;
    ix. Nathan Eddy, b. 19 Aug 1757, m. Mary Allen;
    x. Lois Eddy, b. 30 Dec 1759 at Westport, m. at Westport 29 Apr 1779 Jonathan Gifford (son of Ephraim & Esther Gifford); and
    xi. Gilbert Eddy, b. 12 Jan 1763.