On 4 Nov 1773 when Caleb was 25, he married Patience Bouton (39948) , daughter of Ebenezer Bouton (20377) (ca 1715-29 Jul 1777) & Abigail Crampton (20 Aug 1719-11 Aug 1780), in South Salem, Westchester County, New York. Born ca 1757 in South Salem, Westchester County, New York. Patience was baptized on 8 May 1757. Patience died in Northville, Fulton County, New York on 30 Oct 1819.