On 18 Dec 1764 Judah first married Betty Oldham (31992) , daughter of Caleb Oldham (24115) (27 Jan 1701/2-aft 21 Jun 1785) & Bethiah Stephens (14758) (Feb 1703-aft 1750), in Duxbury, MA. Born ca 1740 in Duxbury, MA. Betty died in Duxbury, MA on 11 Jun 1774.

On 21 Aug 1776 Judah second married Deborah Weston (42241) , daughter of Abner Weston (31622) (ca 1708-2 Aug 1786) & Sarah Standish (22408) (15 Apr 1704-25 Jul 1779), in Duxbury, MA. Born on 28 Aug 1743 in Duxbury, MA.