On 19 Feb 1755 when Elisha was 25, he married Huldah Tilden (31999) , daughter of Thomas Tilden (14765) (30 Jun 1701-bef 14 Jul 1781) & Lettice Turner (23249) (17 Apr 1711-ca 1786), in Windham, CT. Born ca 1732. Huldah died in Windham, CT on 22 Oct 1818.

Children of Elisha and Huldah (Tilden) Lillie, born at Windham:
    i. Jerusha Lillie, b. 20 Oct 1755;
    ii. Huldah Lillie, b. 27 May 1757;
    iii. Jared Lillie, b. 27 Mar 1759;
    iv. Hannah Lillie, b. 23 Sep 1760;
    v. Lydia Lillie, b. 12 Jun 1763;
    vi. Elisha Lillie, b. 21 May 1764;
    vii. Ezra Lillie, b. 5 Sep 1765;
    viii. Lettice Lillie, b. 16 Mar 1767; and
    ix. Lemira Lillie, b. 7 Sep 1768.

In Dec 1754 Jonathan married Hannah Tilden (32001) , daughter of Thomas Tilden (14765) (30 Jun 1701-bef 14 Jul 1781) & Lettice Turner (23249) (17 Apr 1711-ca 1786), in Windham, CT. Born ca 1736 in Marshfield, MA. Hannah died in Windham, CT bef May 1776.

Children of Jonathan and Hannah (Tilden) Lillie:
    i. Turner Lillie, b. 8 Oct 1755, m. Elinor Churchill;
    ii. Elijah Lillie, b. 26 Dec 1756, d. 16 Mar 1844, m. Anne Smith;
    iii. Eunice Lillie, b. 26 Mar 1758, m. Ebenezer Heberd;
    iv. Lucy Lillie, b. 28 Apr 1759, d. 26 Sep 1759;
    v. Lucy Lillie, b. 22 Feb 1761, m. Jeremiah Ormsby;
    vi. Lemeul Lillie; and
    vii. Leonard Lillie.