On 19 Apr 1804 when Samuel was 23, he first married Mary Tuttle. Born on 20 Aug 1785.
Mary, also called Polly. Children of Samuel and Mary (Tuttle) Allen, born at Oriskany Falls, NY:
i. Amos Allen, b. 1 Feb 1805;
ii. James Allen, b. 15 Dec 1806;
iii. Susan Maria Allen, b. 28 Nov 1808;
iv. Augustus Allen, b. 17 Jul 1811;
v. Ransom Allen, b. 13 Dec 1813;
vi. Caroline Ruth Allen, b. 5 May 1816;
vii. Henry Allen, b. 6 May 1818;
viii. Mary Ann Allen, b. 26 Jul 1820, m. Henry Douglas; and
ix. Norman Allen, b. 18 Mar 1824.