## Proposition 2

 If two numbers multiplied by one another make a square number, then they are similar plane numbers. Let A and B be two numbers, and let A multiplied by B make the square number C. I say that A and B are similar plane numbers. Multiply A by itself to make D. Then D is square. Now, since A multiplied by itself makes D, and multiplied by B makes C, therefore A is to B as D is to C. VII.17 And, since D is square, and C is so also, therefore D and C are similar plane numbers. Therefore one mean proportional number falls between D and C. And D is to C as A is to B, therefore one mean proportional number falls between A and B also. VIII.18 VIII.8 But, if one mean proportional number falls between two numbers, then they are similar plane numbers, therefore A and B are similar plane numbers. VIII.20 Therefore, if two numbers multiplied by one another make a square number, then they are similar plane numbers. Q.E.D.
This proposition is a converse of the previous one.

As an example to illustrate this proposition, take any square number, such as 202 = 400. It can be factored as a product of two numbers in several ways. One such factorization is as a = 50 times b = 8. These two numbers have a mean proportional between them, namely, 20, so by VIII.20, they are similar plane numbers. (The actual shapes given by that proposition make 8 to be 2 by 4, and 50 to be 5 by 10.)

#### Outline of the proof

Let a and b be two numbers whose product ab is a square. Now, both a2 and ab are square numbers which means that they're similar plane numbers. By VIII.8, there's a mean proportional between them. But a2:ab = a:b, so there is also a mean proportional between a and b (VIII.8). Therefore, a and b are similar plane figures (VIII.20).

As in the last proof, this one can be shortened. When the product ab is a square, say e2, then a mean proportional between a and b is e.

Next proposition: IX.3

Previous: IX.1

 Select from Book IX Book IX intro IX.1 IX.2 IX.3 IX.4 IX.5 IX.6 IX.7 IX.8 IX.9 IX.10 IX.11 IX.12 IX.13 IX.14 IX.15 IX.16 IX.17 IX.18 IX.19 IX.20 IX.21 IX.22 IX.23 IX.24 IX.25 IX.26 IX.27 IX.27 IX.28 IX.29 IX.30 IX.31 IX.32 IX.33 IX.34 IX.35 IX.36 Select book Book I Book II Book III Book IV Book V Book VI Book VII Book VIII Book IX Book X Book XI Book XII Book XIII Select topic Introduction Table of Contents Geometry applet About the text Euclid Web references A quick trip