In Jun 1707 Jonathan married Sarah FitzRandolph, daughter of John FitzRandolph (ca 1652-) & Sarah Bonham (16 Feb 1664-1737), in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey.463 Born on 25 Apr 1682 in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey.463

26 Jan 1715/6 Phebe married Ephraim Dunham, son of Rev. Edmund Dunham (25 Jul 1661-7 Mar 1733/4) & Mary Bonham (4 Oct 1661-aft 28 Feb 1736/7), in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey.126 Born on 6 May 1695 in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey.

On 12 Jun 1721 Elisha married Mary Dunham, daughter of Rev. Edmund Dunham (25 Jul 1661-7 Mar 1733/4) & Mary Bonham (4 Oct 1661-aft 28 Feb 1736/7), in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey.126 Born on 1 Jul 1700 in Piscataway, Middlesex County, New Jersey. Mary died ca 1731/1737.

On 7 Jun 1725 when Benjamin was 22, he married Mercy Gardener in Westchester.126

Mercy (or Mary) Gardner.

Children of Benjamin and Mary (Gardener) Smalley, born at Piscataway:
    i. Martha Smalley, b. 3 Jul 1726;
    ii. Mary Smalley, b. 22 Dec 1727;
    iii. Experience Smalley, b. 6 Jan 1734/5; and
    iv. John Smalley, b. 8 Apr 1737; also
    v. (perhaps) Benjamin Smalley, b. 26 Oct 1741, but the date would be wrong.126

On July 25, 1737, Mercy Smalley, the widow, was appointed administratrix of the estate of Benjamin Smalley, of Piscataway, Middlesex County, yeoman, who died intestate. (Proceedings of the New Jersey Historical Society, Third Series, vol. 3: 14.)126