On 23 Nov 1738 when Mary was 16, she first married Stephen Paine in Braintree, MA. Born on 8 Jan 1717 in Braintree, MA. Stephen died in Braintree, MA, on 18 Jul 1739; he was 22.

Stephen, son of Samuel and Rachel (Hayden) Paine.

On 18 Aug 1740 when Mary was 18, she second married Gideon Stetson (42627) , son of Robert Stetson (22751) (9 Dec 1670-1760) & Mary Collamore (49255) (10 Nov 1667-).284 Born on 19 Jul 1709 in Scituate, MA.52 Gideon was baptized on 24 Jul 1709. Gideon died in Scituate, MA in 1761. Occupation: Currier. Marriage intention published on 12 Jul 1740 at Scituate, MA.52

Gideon first married Lydia Pitcher, second Mary (Littlefield) Paine, widow of Stephen Paine.