On 13 Mar 1778 when Bethuel was 33, he married
Caroline Lord (32129) , daughter of
Epaphras Lord (26 Dec 1709-25 Nov 1799) &
Lucy Bulkeley (14919) (29 Jan 1719/20-10 May 1800), in Hebron, CT.
6 Born on 2 Mar 1758 in Colchester, CT.6 Caroline died in Warehouse Point, Windsor, CT, on 20 Dec 1819; she was 61.116
Children of Bethuel and Caroline (Lord) Phelps:
i. Lydia Phelps, b. 22 Apr 1779 at Hebron, d. 17 Nov 1833 at Saratoga Springs, Saratoga Co., NY, m. Horace Barber (b. 2 Oct 1776 at Warehouse Point, CT, d. there 17 Feb 1839), resided at Warehouse Point;
ii. Epaphras Lord Phelps, b. 16 May 1783 at Tolland, d. 28 Jun 1868, m. 1st 1810 Elizabeth Holkins (b. 12 Feb 1791 at Warehouse Point, d. there 27 Oct 1827), m. 2nd 2 Dec 1833 Clarissa (Porter) Sparhawk (b. 21 Jun 1791 at Windsor, CT, d. 22 Mar 1855 at East Windsor, widow of Dr. Jonathan Sparhawk), resided at Hebron, Warehouse Point, and East Windsor;
iii. Charles Stiles Phelps, b. 12 Mar 1789 at Tolland, d. 8 Feb 1870 at Brooklyn, NY, Rev., m. 1st at Longmeadow, MA, Aug 1819 Flavia Burt (d. 1820), m. 2nd 1822 Harriett Stebbins Morgan (b. 25 Jun 1801 at Pittsfield, MA, d. Apr 1827 at Hartford, CT), m. 3rd 1838 Catherine Warren (d. 1852), m. 4th 1853 Elizabeth Saxton Newcomb (d. ca. 1888/9), resided at Warehouse Point, Hartford, Oswego, NY, and in 1860 went to Brooklyn.6