On 15 Oct 1732 John married Mary Allin (35199) , daughter of Matthew Allin (20 Nov 1675-aft 1737) & Phebe Cook (16776) (3 Sep 1677-aft 1717), in Portsmouth, RI.322 John Fish, son of Preserved and Ruth, and Mary Allen, dau. of Matthew and Phebe, were married by William Sanford, Justice, 15 Oct 1732. Born on 18 Apr 1710 in Portsmouth, RI.322

Children of John and Mary (Allen) Fish, born at Portsmouth:
    i. Phebe Fish, b. 21 May 1733;
    ii. Allen Fish, b. 21 May 1735;
    iii. Ruth Fish, b. 23 May 1737; and
    iv. Lillis Fish, b. 2 Apr 1740.322

Ca 1740 Benjamin first married Priscilla Arthur. Priscilla died in Portsmouth, RI on 1 Apr 1774.

Priscilla, daughter of John and Mary (Folger) Arthur.

On 3 Apr 1776 when Benjamin was 59, he second married Patience Tallman (22926) , daughter of Benjamin Tallman (8596) (28 Jan 1683/4-20 May 1759) & Patience Durfee (19 Jun 1690-ca 1723), in Portsmouth, RI. Born on 6 Apr 1721 in Portsmouth, RI.322