Lucy first married Jedediah Dudley.

Lucy second married Dan Johnson (47200) , son of Daniel Johnson (35565) (1707 [error for 1708]-14 Oct 1780) & Joanna Preston (28803) (18 Mar 1714-18 Jan 1781). Born on 13 Mar 1746 in Wallingford, CT.90 Dan died in Wallingford, CT, on 2 Sep 1830; he was 84.55 Buried in Center Street Cemetery, Wallingford.