On 31 Aug 1737 when Experience was 19, she first married Ichabod Simmons (41166) , son of William Simmons (21443) (24 Sep 1672-8 Jan 1765) & Abigail Church (23818) (1 Jun 1680-4 Jul 1720), in Bristol, RI. Born on 6 Jun 1715 in Little Compton, RI.271 Ichabod died on 1 Jan 1750; he was 34.

On 15 Aug 1753 when Experience was 35, she second married Samuel Whitaker, son of Richard Whitaker (10 May 1699-) & Ann Wood, in Bristol, RI. Born on 3 Nov 1727 in Rehoboth, MA.