On 13 Oct 1767 when Aaron was 20, he first married Lydia Taylor.433 Born on 27 Oct 1745 in Sutton, MA. Lydia died in Sutton, MA, on 4 Mar 1825; she was 79.

Lydia, daughter of James and Lydia Taylor.

On 7 Dec 1825 when Aaron was 78, he second married Susanna Davis, daughter of Ebenezer Davis (11 Nov 1717-ca May 1792) & Lydia Dana (Sep 1724-1792), in Sutton, MA.566 Born on 13 Jan 1764 in Oxford, MA.515 Susanna died in Oxford, MA, on 20 Apr 1845; she was 81.

Susanna first married John Carriel, second Aaron Elliott as his second wife.