On 22 Sep 1779 when Elisha was 22, he first married Molly Pettingill in Duxbury, MA. Born on 9 Jan 1760 in Duxbury, MA.

On 15 Sep 1812 when Elisha was 55, he second married Chloe Sylvester (51081) , daughter of Elisha Sylvester (42975) (say 1724-17 Jul 1805) & Grace Ruggles (33886) (11 Sep 1725-Apr 1776). Born on 23 Jul 1765 in Scituate, MA.52 Chloe died in Sumner, Oxford County, Maine, on 22 Apr 1850; she was 84. Buried in Bonney Road Cemetery, Sumner.