On 17 Apr 1794 when Susannah was 57, she first married Dea. Phineas Peck (48143) , son of Jeremiah Peck (32136) (5 Sep 1687-5 Oct 1765) & Hannah Fiske (30388) (ca 1693-), in Woodbridge, CT.64 Born on 10 Apr 1723 in Milford, CT.65 Phineas was baptized in First Church of Milford, on 14 Apr 1723.64 Phineas died in Woodbridge, CT, on 28 Jan 1803; he was 79.64 Buried in North Cemetery, Woodbridge.

On 19 May 1773 when Susannah was 36, she second married Stephen Hine (33980) , son of Ambrose Hine (16119) (ca 1691-1750) & Sarah Raper (30 Sep 1697-), in Woodbridge, CT. Born ca 1721. Stephen died in Woodbridge, CT on 11 Sep 1791.