On 8 Jul 1746 Amy first married Joseph Arnold (37668) , son of Joseph Arnold (18317) (ca 1678-4 Nov 1746) & Mercy Stafford (21 Sep 1694-Dec 1779), in Providence, RI. Married by Ebenezer Jenckes, Justice. Born on 30 Apr 1718 in Providence, RI. Joseph died on 11 Dec 1750; he was 32.

On 30 Aug 1752 Amy second married Joshua Arnold (37674) , son of Joseph Arnold (18317) (ca 1678-4 Nov 1746) & Mercy Stafford (21 Sep 1694-Dec 1779), in Smithfield, RI.561 Married by Thomas Lapham, Justice. Born on 12 Jul 1729 in Providence, RI. Joshua died in Smithfield, RI in Jul 1818.