On 13 Jun 1751 when Abigail was 19, she first married Gideon Bearse (45149) , son of John Bearse (8 May 1687-6 Apr 1761) & Sarah Holmes (25866) (11 Apr 1703-). Born on 6 Mar 1721 in Plympton, MA.

On 31 May 1770 when Abigail was 38, she second married Caleb Sturtevant (38733) , son of James Sturtevant (28266) (ca 1687-8 May 1756) & Susannah Cooke (19386) (ca 1689-Oct 1769), in Halifax, MA. Born 16 Mar 1715/6 in Plympton, MA.265 Caleb died in Halifax, MA on 7 Oct 1793.

Caleb first married Patience Cushman, second Abigail (Ripley) Bearse, widow of Gideon Bearse.

From the Halifax town records: “May 31 1770 Caleb Sturtevant and Abigail Bearce both of Halifax were joyned in marriage by Mr Briggs.”