On 21 Aug 1863 when Lucinda Elizabeth was 26, she married Lyman Arehart, son of Henry Arehart (6 Sep 1813-2 Sep 1893) & Mary Evers (22 Mar 1809-20 Jun 1887), in Morrow County, Ohio. Born on 5 May 1840 in Knox County, Ohio. Lyman died in Knox County, Ohio, on 27 Jan 1922; he was 81. Buried in David City Cemetery.

1870 Federal Census. Etna, Kosciusko County, Indiana
Roll 332, page 312B
Post Office Edna Green
    Lymon Arehart, 30, farmer, $700 personal estate, b. OH
    Lucinda Arehart, 32, keeping house, b. OH
    Henry I. Arehart, 7, b. OH
    William Arehart, 6, b. OH
    John F. Arehart, 3, b. IN

1885 Nebrasksa Census. Franklin, Butler County
L. Arehart, 45, farmer, b. OH, father b. PA, mother b. Me.[?]
    Lucinda Arehart, 48, wife, keeps house, b. OH, father b. PA, mother b. Me.[?]
    Henry Arehart, 21, son, farmer, b. OH, parents b. OH
    Margaret Arehart, 14, daughter, b. NE, parents b. OH
    William Arehart, 20, son, farmer, b. OH, parents b. OH
    John Arehart, 17, son, farmer, b. IN, parents b. OH
    Lucy Arehart, 11, daughter, b. NE, parents b. OH
    Lucinda Tabor, 7, niece, b. ditto
The familiy is listed right after two Grubaugh families.

David City Cemetery, David City, Butler County, Nebraska
    Lyman Arehart, 1840–1922
    Lucinda Arehart, 1836–1923

On 29 Mar 1860 when James Wesley was 22, he first married Jane Shaffer, daughter of William Shaffer (Oct 1791-29 Jun 1857) & Catherine (7 Jan 1803-9 Sep 1883), in Ashland County, Ohio. Born on 9 Sep 1839 in Ohio. Jane died in Tippecanoe, Marshall County, Indiana, on 18 Oct 1878; she was 39. Buried in Summit Chapel Cemetery, Bourbon.

1850 Federal Census. Jackson, Mahoning County, Ohio
Roll 707, page 497A
    William Shafer, 51, farmer, $1380 real estate, b. PA
    Catherine Shafer, 48, b. PH
    Ann Shafer, 15, b. OH
    Jane Shafer, 12, b. OH
    Hiram Shafer, 8, b. OH
    Margaret Shafer, 1, b. OH

On 7 Jan 1882 when James Wesley was 43, he second married Mary J. Lee in Tippecanoe, Marshall County, Indiana.

On 8 Aug 1861 when John Henry was 20, he married Margaret Shaffer, daughter of Jacob Shaffer (ca 1796-) & Margery Cunningham (ca 1800-), in Holmes County, Ohio. Born on 21 Sep 1840 in Ohio. Margaret died in Licking County, Ohio, on 27 Sep 1892; she was 52. Buried in Linnville Cemetery.

Margaret, known as Maggy or Marjory, Shaffer. She first married John Grubaugh, second John Lewis, and third Martin Van Buren Garrison.

Indiana Marriage Index
18 Jul 1866, Marshall County
    John Lewis and Margery Grubaugh

Linnville Cemetery, Linnville, Licking County, Ohio
    Maggie, wife of M.V.B. Garrison, died Sept. 27, 1892, aged 52 y. 6 d.

On 15 Feb 1866 when David P. was 25, he first married Isabell Garverick, daughter of Henry Garverick (3 Oct 1802-2 Feb 1886) & Barbara Sheffer (3 Dec 1806-2 Sep 1888), in Morrow County, Ohio. Born on 3 Oct 1837 in Ohio. Isabell died in Markle, Indiana, on 19 Apr 1903; she was 65. Buried in Hoverstock Cemetery, Zanesville.

Isabel first married Jacob P. Neff, second David Grubaugh.

Fort Wayne News, 21 Apr1903
    Mrs. David Gubaugh, the mother of Mrs. William Lakey, of this city, died Sunday evening at her home in Markle, IN, aged 65 years, of paralysis. A husband, three sons and one daughter are the surviving family. The funeral and interment will be held at Zanesville tomorrow. The family formerly resided in Wells county for many years.

On 12 Sep 1907 when David P. was 67, he second married Mary Ann Williams, daughter of Daniel Williams & Elnora Livingston, in Huntington County, Indiana. Born on 2 Oct 1838 in Marion County, Ohio. Mary Ann died in Huntington, Huntington County, Indiana, on 25 Jan 1916; she was 77. Buried in Barnes Chapel Cemetery.

Mary first married a Mr Drabenstott.

Barnes Chapel Cemetery, Browns Corner, Huntington County, Indiana
    Mary Ann Grubaugh, d. 25 Jan 1916
Plot: Row 2

On 27 May 1869 when William Jefferson was 24, he first married Rachel E. Arehart, daughter of Henry Arehart (6 Sep 1813-2 Sep 1893) & Mary Evers (22 Mar 1809-20 Jun 1887), in Kosciusko County, Indiana. Born in 1851 in Richland County, Ohio. Rachel E. died in Butler County, Nebraska on 29 Aug 1871.


Edholm Cemetery, Octavia, Butler County, Nebraska
    Rachel E., wife of Wm. J. Grubaugh, died Aug 20, 1871, aged 21 yrs [can’t read months]

On 21 Mar 1877 when William Jefferson was 31, he second married Josephine Abney in Adams County, Illinois. Born on 20 Jun 1861 in Quincy, Adams County, Illinois. Josephine died in Santa Clara, Santa Clara County, California, on 8 Nov 1945; she was 84.


Saratoga IOOF Cemetery, Saratoga, Santa Clara County, California
    Joseph Grubaugh, 1861–1945
Plot: row 36, section B, plot 3
Either the cemetery records misspelled her name or she whent by the nickname Joseph.

On 24 Jan 1871 when Rachel Mary was 23, she married Samuel Adams Crocker, son of Thomas Jefferson Crocker (28 Oct 1823-7 Sep 1895) & Susan Ann M. Gillespie (8 Sep 1827-30 Apr 1889). Born on 4 Feb 1849 in Jamestown, Clinton County, Illinois. Samuel Adams died in David City, Butler County, Nebraska, on 7 Sep 1914; he was 65. Buried in David City Cemetery.


David City Cemetery, David City, Butler County, Nebraska
    Samuel A. Crocker, b. 4 Feb 1849, d. 7 Sep 1914
    Rachel Crocker, d. 30 Mar 1902

On 23 Feb 1875 when George K. was 24, he married Henrietta Jane Crocker, daughter of Thomas Jefferson Crocker (28 Oct 1823-7 Sep 1895) & Susan Ann M. Gillespie (8 Sep 1827-30 Apr 1889). Born on 2 May 1856 in Illinois. Henrietta Jane died bef 1900.

On 11 Apr 1875 when Sarah Elizabeth was 22, she married George Hansen Tabler, son of William Tabler (ca 1778-1 Dec 1844) & Elizabeth Samson (ca 1800-8 Sep 1881), in Butler, Worthington Township, Richland County, Ohio. Born on 22 Aug 1839 in Wheeling, Ohio County, West Virginia. George Hansen died in Valley, Douglas County, NE, on 24 Mar 1906; he was 66. Buried in Elk City Cemetery.


Elk City Cemetery, Elk City, Douglas County, Nebraska
    George H. Tabler, b. 22 Aug 1839, d. 24 Mar 1906, Pvt Co K, 3 Iowa Cav

On 1 Apr 1877 when Mathew Palmer was 21, he married Lenora Jane Snavely, daughter of Samuel Houston Snavely (ca 1829-) & Helen Roxy Tabor (ca 1833-bef 1880), in David City, Butler County, Nebraska. Born on 20 Jan 1861 in La Porte County, Indiana. Lenora Jane died in David City, Butler County, Nebraska, on 16 Sep 1940; she was 79. Buried in David City Cemetery.