On 27 Feb 1733 when Caleb was 33, he second married
Elizabeth Plumb (30802) , daughter of
Joseph Plumb (13487) (ca 1683-27 May 1742) &
Elizabeth Bailey (-17 Nov 1726), in Wallingford, CT.
55 Born 17 Mar 1709/10 in Milford, CT.64 Elizabeth was baptized in First Church of Milford, on 8 Jun 1718.64 Elizabeth died aft 25 Dec 1751.