On 31 Dec 1762 when Gideon was 25, he first married
Prudence Tuttle (56268) , daughter of
Dan Tuttle (30 Aug 1722-1784) &
Phebe Beach (42186) (2 Jan 1725-), in New Haven, CT.
55 Born on 24 Jun 1745 in Wallingford, CT.90 Prudence died in North Haven, CT, on 10 Dec 1798; she was 53.55 Buried in Old Graveyard, North Haven.
Children of Gideon and Prudence (Tuttle) Todd:
i. Caleb, b. 31 Jan 1764, d. 18 Aug 1843, Capt., m. at North Haven 25 Oct 1784 Hannah Goodsell (b. ca. 1766, bp. 15 Aug 1770 at East Haven, dau. of Penfield & Hannah (Thompson) Goodsell), removed about 1800 to Fairfield, Herkimer Co., NY;
ii. Justus Lyman, b. 5 Mar 1766, d. 28 May 1844 at North Haven, m. Elizabeth Penfield Goodsell (bp. 15 Apr 1770 at East Haven, d. summer 1841 at North Haven, sister of Hannah who married Justus’s brother Caleb);
iii. Samuel Beach, b. 5 Apr 1768, d. 12 Mar 1852 at Fairfield, NY, m. 1st at North Haven 1 Jul 1790 Lowly Humiston (b. 14 Jul 1772 at New Haven, d. 5 Oct 1794 at North Haven, dau. of Samuel & Mary (Gill) Humiston), m. 2nd at North Haven 19 Feb 1795 Sarah (widow of Levi Brockett), m. 3rd Polly Rice, resided at Fairfield, NY, in 1805;
iv. Lucinda, b. 22 Apr 1770, d. 24 Mar 1804 at North Haven, m. James Pierpont (bp. 22 Jul 1764 at North Haven, d. there 1830);
v. Melicu, b. 31 Aug 1773, d. 4 Aug 1816 at North Haven, m. there 20 Nov 1799 Polly Ray (b. 19 Jan 1779 at North Haven, d. there 19 Aug 1841, dau. of Levi & Mary (Cooper) Ray);
vi. Sally, b. 19 Jul 1776, d. 29 Dec 1865, m. at North Haven 23 Jul 1800 Benjamin Baldwin;
vii. Clarissa, b. 26 Nov 1779, d. 25 Oct 1803 at North Hvaen, m. there 23 Jan 1799 Samuel Chapman;
viii. Aurilla, b. 20 Jul 1781, m. at North Haven 30 Mar 1800 Benajah Todd;
ix. Betsey, b. 24 Jan 1787, d. 12 Jul 1794 at North Haven;
x. John, b. 4 Feb 1791, d. 9 Apr 1861 at North Haven, m. there 29 Nov 1813 Lewey Pierpont (b. ca. 1795, d. 10 mar 1887 at North Haven, dau. of Joel & Hannah (Clinton) Pierpont).55