On 31 Oct 1704 when John was 24, he married Elizabeth Cook, daughter of Noah Cook (14 Jun 1657-1 Jun 1699) & Sarah Nash. Born ca 1685 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts. Elizabeth was baptized in Hartford, CT, on 29 Mar 1685. Elizabeth died in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts on 18 Oct 1761.

On 26 Oct 1705 when Nathaniel was 24, he married Hannah Sheldon, daughter of Capt. John Sheldon (8 Dec 1658-ca 1733) & Hannah Stebbins (8 Jul 1664-29 Feb 1704), in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts. Born on 8 Oct 1683 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts.161 Hannah died in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts, on 13 Jul 1764; she was 80.161

Hannah first married Joseph Catlin, second Nathaniel Clark.

She was in the Benoni Stebbins house with her husband and was wounded in the attack.161

2 Feb 1709/10 Increase married Mary Sheldon (29639) , daughter of Isaac Sheldon (4 Sep 1656-29 Mar 1712) & Sarah Warner (12731) (ca 1664-).294 Born on 18 Sep 1690 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts.294 Mary died on 6 Aug 1767; she was 76.294

On 23 Dec 1719 when Josiah was 22, he married Thankful Sheldon (29642) , daughter of Isaac Sheldon (4 Sep 1656-29 Mar 1712) & Sarah Warner (12731) (ca 1664-).294 Born on 6 Jun 1698 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts.294 Thankful died on 20 Feb 1774; she was 75.294