On 10 Dec 1772 when Elisha was 33, he married Rebecca Stetson (42696) , daughter of Nathaniel Stetson (22780) (Jun 1700-28 Jul 1753) & Rebecca Brisco, in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446 Born in May 1743 in Hanover, MA.284 Rebecca died in Chesterfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts on 18 Apr 1803.

Elisha Witherell was of Chesterfield and Widow Rebecca Studley of Hanover when they married.446