On 30 Jan 1725 when Theophilus was 21, he first married Mehitable Bryant, daughter of Stephen Bryant (1 May 1684-ca 1747) & Bathsheba Briggs (11 Jan 1683/4-aft 1748), in Abington, MA. Born on 23 Jun 1704 in Pembroke, MA. Mehitable died in Pembroke, MA, on 6 Jun 1733; she was 28.

On 22 May 1734 when Theophilus was 31, he second married Sarah Riccards in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446 Sarah died in Hanover, MA on 4 Sep 1751.

Sarah Record, or Riccards.

Theophilus was of Hanover and Sarah of Pembroke when they married.446

In 1752 Theophilus third married Desire Bishop (34465) , daughter of John Bishop (28 Apr 1677-Feb 1756) & Elizabeth Keen (16433) (ca 1678-9 Apr 1745). Born on 26 Feb 1710 in Pembroke, MA.

23 Mar 1726/7 Isabel first married Edmond Bowker, son of James Bowker (ca 1645-14 Oct 1724) & Mary, in the Second Church of Scituate.52 Born on 15 Aug 1704 in Scituate, MA. Edmond died on 2 May 1729; he was 24.

Edmund was of Pembroke when he married Isabel.

8 Aug 1731/2 Isabel second married Jacob Wilkie in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446

Jacob Wilke was of Tiverton when he married Isabel.446

On 18 Jul 1731 when Joseph was 22, he married Elizabeth Sherman (22416) , daughter of Ebenezer Sherman (8389) (21 Apr 1680-1 Feb 1759) & Margaret Decrow (13283) (10 Jan 1679/80-17 Mar 1726), in Marshfield, MA.123 Born on 27 Jan 1706 in Marshfield, MA.60 Elizabeth died aft 1779.

Children of Joseph and Elizabeth (Sherman) Witherell include
    i. Joseph Witherell, b.ca 1u32, d. 7 May 1818 at Pembroke;
    ii. Desire Witherell, m. 11 Jan 1775 Ashur Keene as his second wife;
    iii. Eunice Witherell, b. ca. 1739, d. 1767, m. 29 Jan 1767 Ichabod Bearse (b. 23 Ocdt 1744, d. 25 Feb 1815, son of Thomas & Abigail (Tubbs) Bearse);
    iv. Joshua Witherell, b. ca. 1741, d. 28 Nov 1812, m. 25 Dec 1769 Mary Standish;
    v. Mary Witherell, b. 1742, d. 4 May 1810; and
    vi. Amos Witherell, b. ca. 1745, d. 8 Aug 1823, m. 24 Dec 1767 Ruth Stetson (b. 1747, d. 8 Jan 1811).123

On 19 Apr 1736 Samuel married Rebecca Ferris in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446 Rebecca died in Hanover, MA ca 1785.

Samuel and Rebecca were both of Hanover when they married.446

Children of Samuel and Rebecca (Ferris) Witherell, born at Hanover:
    i. Samuel Witherell, b. ca. 1737, d. after 1810 at Shoreham, VT;
    ii. infant child, d. Jan 1737;
    iii. Seth Witherell, b. ca 1738, d. before 10 Aug 1798 at East Hartford, CT, m. at Hanover 29 Nov 1764 Hannah Clark (b. 23 Jul 1745 at Hanover, d. 1821 at East Hartford);
    iv. Elisha Witherell, b. 16 Jun 1739, d. 28 Jul 1831 at Chesterfield, MA, m. at Hanover 30 Dec 1772 Rebecca Stetson (b. May 1743 at Scituate, d. 18 Apr 1803 at Chesterfield, dau. of Nathaniel & Rebecca (Briscoe) Stetson);
    v. John Witherell, b. 1740, d. 28 May 1774 at Hanover, m. there 17 Dec 1761 Content Conneway;
    vi. Mercy Witherell, b. ca. 1747, d. Feb 1825, m. at Hanover 12 Apr 1766 Lemuel Bates (b. Jul 1738 at Hanover);
    vii. Simeon Witherell, b. 1748, d. ca. 1810 at Scituate, m. at Hanover 2 Jan 1777 Mary Pierce (b. 11 Aug 1759 at Scituate, d. there 30 May 1839);
    viii. infant child, d. 11 May 1748; and
    ix. James Witherell, b. ca. 1752, m. at Hanover 11 Mar 1773 (b. 21 Feb 1756 at Sandwich, MA).

On 27 Sep 1734 when Eunice was 21, she married Samuel Perry (9927) , son of Henry Perry (3341) (say1658-bet 29 Mar 1733 and 13 Sep 1734) & Mary Pratt (ca 1662-), in Pembroke, MA.395 Born on 24 Aug 1701 in Pembroke, MA. Samuel died in Pembroke, MA, on 16 Feb 1781; he was 79.

On 5 Oct 1738 when Timothy was 23, he married Sarah Caswell (57740) , daughter of Job Caswell (45707) (ca 1694-5 Nov 1774) & Lydia Peckham (19 Mar 1706-14 Dec 1760), in Newport, RI. Born ca 1720.

On 18 Dec 1739 when Mary was 23, she married Samuel Hessord in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446

On 15 May 1740 when Hannah was 19, she married Nathaniel Robbins in First Congegational Church of Hanover.446 Born ca 1720. Nathaniel died in Marshfield, MA on 17 Dec 1774.174

From Deane’s History of Scituate:53
    Nathaniel Robbins, of Marshfield, married Hannah, the daughter of Samuel Witherell, and grand-daughter of Rev. William Witherell, and deceased in middle life, leaving 4 sons.

From A historical sketch of the town of Hanover:174
    Nathaniel lived in Hanover, first in the ‘Beech woods country,’ and then at the corner of Grove st, where the cellar hole to his house is yet visible. He was killed in Marshfield by the falling in of the stones of a well, on which he was at work; as the record says, Dec. 17, 1774, but as family tradition says, June 17, 1775, the fall of the stones being occasioned by the jarring of the earth, induced by the firing of the cannon at the battle of Bunker Hill.