On 23 Feb 1783 when Andrew was 25, he first married Rachel Cutter in Rindge, Cheshire County, New Hampshire. Born on 6 Apr 1763. Rachel died in Rindge, Cheshire County, New Hampshire, on 10 Apr 1786; she was 23. Buried in Meeting House Cemetery, Rindge.

Rachel, daughter of Nathan and Hannah Cutter.

On 29 May 1787 when Andrew was 29, he second married Parna Sawyer in Boylston, MA. Born on 16 Sep 1761 in Lancaster, MA. Parna died on 20 May 1788; she was 26.

Parna, daughter of Aaron and Abigail (Moore) Sawyer. She first married Abraham Howe, second Andrew Kimball.

On 15 Feb 1791 when Andrew was 33, he third married Prudence Fuller in Lunenburg, MA. Born on 21 Oct 1759 in Lunenburg, MA.

Prudence, daughter of John and Prudence (Gibson) Fuller. She first married Clark Carlton, second Andrew Kimball.

On 20 May 1792 when Andrew was 34, he fourth married Polly Barker (50688) , daughter of Barnabas Barker (33586) (13 Apr 1723-23 Mar 1797) & Sarah Greene (43644) (27 Dec 1723-20 Feb 1797), in Rindge, Cheshire County, New Hampshire. Born ca 1754 in Scituate, MA. Polly was baptized in the Second Church of Scituate, on 7 Apr 1754.335 Polly died in Rindge, Cheshire County, New Hampshire on 27 Jul 1796. Buried in Meeting House Cemetery, Rindge.

Polly, also called Mary, Barker.

On 13 Feb 1798 when Andrew was 40, he fifth married Elizabeth Hill in Billerica, MA. Born on 13 Oct 1759 in Billerica, MA. Elizabeth died in Rindge, Cheshire County, New Hampshire, on 20 May 1830; she was 70. Buried in Meeting House Cemetery, Rindge.

Elizabeth, daughter of Jonathan and Mary (Lane) Hill.