On 10 May 1737 Dorothy married John Phelps (21815) , son of Cornelius Phelps (8099) (26 Apr 1671-ca 1740/1) & Sarah Mansfield (32109) (5 Jan 1685/6-1774), in Lyme, CT.116 Born on 6 Jul 1710 in Windsor, CT.115 John died on 9 Sep 1776; he was 66.

From The Phelps Family of America:116
    (#178) John Phelps, b. Windsor, Ct., 6 July, 1710, m. Elizabeth, who d. Windsor, Ct., leaving 2 children who d. young. He m. 2nd, Dorothy Rathbone, 10 May, 1737, at Lyme, Ct.
    Mr. Phelps resided in Windsor, Ct., and Simsbury, and died 1 Sept., 1776.
    Children by 1st wife, b. Windsor, Ct.:
    i. David, d. Jan. or 6 June, 1732-3.
    ii. John, d. July, 1734.
    Children by 2nd wife, b. Windsor, Ct., (except 6th and 7th.:)
    iii. Nathaniel, b. 1738, m. Triphene ——.
    iv. A daughter, b. 1749. m. —— Grant.
    v. Harlow, b. 1742, m. ——.
    vi. Charles, b. Lyme, Ct., 22 July, 1738.
    vi. John Clement, b. Lyme, Ct.
(Record of this family not satisfactory.)