On 3 Dec 1761 when Nathaniel was 25, he first married Sarah Bishop in Pembroke, MA.284 Born ca 1736 in Pembroke, MA. Sarah died in Pembroke, MA on 27 Jan 1808.284

Sarah, daughter of Josiah Bishop.284

On 18 Feb 1810 when Nathaniel was 74, he second married Deborah Bowker in Pembroke, MA.395

Deborah first married Isaac Oldham, second Alexander Soper as his second wife, and third Nathaniel Stetson as his second wife.

From the Pembroke town records: Isaac Oldhum Jun^r to Deborah Beuker both of Pembroke Feb. ye 12^th 1746 [should be 1756 as all the surrounding records have]

On 2 Apr 1761 when Abisha was 22, he married Sarah Crocker in Pembroke, MA.284 Born on 28 Oct 1743 in Pembroke, MA. Sarah died in East Bridgewater, MA, on 20 Nov 1810; she was 67. Buried in Old Graveyard, East Bridgewater.

Sarah, daughter of Jonathan and Bethiah (Lowden) Crocker, also spelled Crooker.