On 15 Oct 1920 when Winfield Scott was 67, he second married
Mary Jane Dunbar, daughter of
Alvin Benson Dunbar (27 Mar 1827-4 Mar 1926) &
Julia S. Britton (2 Feb 1851-6 Dec 1934), in West Branch, Ogemaw County, Michigan.
Born on 25 May 1867 in New York. They were divorced.
Mary first married John Pero, second Christian Rentschler as his second wife, third Isaac Adams, then Christian Rentschler again, then Winfield Cramer as his second wife, then George Muntz.
1870 Federal Census. Lee, Oneida County, New York
Roll 1059, page 364A
Post Office Lee Center
Alvin Dunbar, 32, farmer, $700 real estate
Julia Dunbar, 19, keeping house, parents of foreign birth
Mary Dunbar, 3
Sylvia Dunbar, 1
John Dunbar, 73, farm laborer
Rachel Dunbar, 69, keeping house
All were born in New York.
1880 Federal Census. Lee, Oneida County, New York
Roll 902, page 313D
Alvin Dunbar, 42, farmer, b. NY, parents b. NY
Julia Dunbar, 29, housekeeper, b. NY, parents b. France
Mary J. Dunbar, 13, works out, b. NY, parents b. NY
Silvia Dunbar, 11, helps at home, b. ditto
Eliza Dunbar, 9, b. ditto
Henry Dunbar, 8, b. ditto
Ebin Dunbar, 7, b. ditto
George Dunbar, 6, b. ditto
Fredrick Dunbar, 4, b. ditto
Lewella Dunbar, 2, b. ditto
Lewis Dunbar, 9 months, b. ditto
Lucy Dunbar, 9 months, b. ditto
Michigan Marriages
Return of Marriages in the County of Ogemaw
29 Apr 1886, Beaver Lake Twp. L.M. Wright, Minister of the Gospel. Witnesses Henry Van Martee of Beaver Lake & Addie Kurn of West Branch
John Pero, 21, of Clare Co. MI, b. Canada, lumberman
Mary J. Dunbar, 18, of Clare Co. MI, b. New York
1900 Federal Census. West Branch, Ogemaw County, Michigan
Roll 736, page 11A
First Street
Christian Rentschler, head, b. Sep 1858, 41, m. 12 years, b. Germany, parents b. Germany, imm. 1862, common laborer
Mary J. Rentschler, wife, b. May 1868, 32, 32, m. 12 years, 10 children, 7 living, b. NY, parents b. NY
Myrtle Rentschler, daugher, b. Jan 1889, 11, b. MI, father b. Germany, mother b. NY, student
Henry Rentschler, son, b. Jul 1894, 5, b. ditto
Hazen P. Rentschler, son, b. Jan 1897, 3, b. ditto
Elmer Rentschler, son, b. May 1898, 2, b. ditto
Violet Rentschler, daughter, b. APr 1899, 1, b. ditto
Michigan Marriages
Return of Marriages in the County of Ogemaw
18 Nov 1907, West Branch. S.C. Robinson, Minister. Witnesses Laura B. French & Mrs. S.C. Robinson, both of West Branch
Isaac Adams, 64, of Ogemaw Co., b. MI, farmer, son of Salomen Adams & Jerusha Leach
Mary J. (Dunbar) Rentschler, 41, of Ogemaw Co., b. New York, house keeperdaughter of A.B. Dunbar & Julia Britton
Michigan Marriages
Return of Marriages in the County of Charlevoix
2 Jul 1909, Boyne City. F.M. Taylor, Clergyman. Witnesses B.H. Taylor & Mrs. M.M. Gray, both of Boyne City
Christian Rentschler, 50, of Boyne City, b. Germany, laborer, son of Christian Rentschler, married once before
Mary J. Rentschler, 41, of Boyne City, b. New York, daughter of Alvan Dunbar, married twice before
Michigan Marriages
Return of Marriages in the County of Ogemaw
7 Jul 1925, West Branch. J.T. Millard, J.P. Witnesses Mrs. Frank Gavin & G.J. Vooyhie
George Muntz, 66, of Ogemaw Co., b. Tuscola Co. MI, farmer, son of George Muntz & Frances Ricker, married once before
Mary (Dunbar) Rentchler, 59, of Ogemaw Co., b. NY, housewife, daughter of Alvin Dunbar & Mary Britton, married twice before
1930 Federal Census. West Branch, Ogemaw County, Michigan
Roll 1020, page 1A
George Muntz, head, 70, m. age 24, b. MI, parents b. Germany, [retired]
Mary J. Muntz, wife, 61, m. age 18, b. NY, parents b. NY
Albert Rentchler, [step-]grandson, 10, b. MI, father b. MI, mother b. Kentucky
Julia Dunbar, mother[-in-law], 79, widowed, m. age 16, b. NY, parents b. France