By 1654 Benjamin first married Susanna Jenny, daughter of John Jenny (ca 1589-1643/4) & Sarah Carey (ca 1590-).16 Born ca 1629/1634 in Plymouth, MA. Susanna died in Plymouth, MA bef 18 Aug 1655.188

Ca 1656 Benjamin second married Sarah Brewster (3413) , daughter of Love Brewster (3286) (ca 1611-31 Jan 1650) & Sarah Collier (1368) (ca 1616-26 Apr 1691), in Duxbury, MA.184 Born ca 1635 in Plymouth, MA.298 Sarah died in Duxbury, MA aft 1670.

One or more of Benjamin’s children–Ebenezer, Sarah, and Ichabod–may be the children of his third wife Cicily rathern then of Sarah.188

Bef 31 Jan 1678 Benjamin third married Cicily.188 Cicily died aft 1 Sep 1691.188

Cicily, or Sissila, perhaps Freeman, Covel, or Nickerson. She may have been the mother of one or more of Benjamin’s children: Ebenezer, Sarah, and Ichabod.188

On 20 Dec 1649 Rebecca married Sergeant William Harlow in Plymouth, MA.62 Born ca 1624.188 William died in Plymouth, MA on 25 Aug 1691.63 Occupation: cooper.

William appeared as a young man in Lynn, MA, in 1637, then moved to Sandwich and later to Plymouth. He was sworn a freeman 6 Jun 1654 and served in the military.

On 10 Sep 1651 Mary first married Richard Foster in Plymouth, MA.62 Richard died 1658/59.298

Richard, of Plymouth, served against the Narragansetts from 15 Aug 1645.

On 8 Jul 1659 Mary second married Jonathan Mowry (5520) , son of Roger Mowry (ca 1610-5 Jan 1666[/7]) & Mary Johnson (2205) (ca 1614-Jan 1678/9), in Plymouth, MA.62 Born ca 1633 in Salem, MA.188 Jonathan was baptized in Salem, MA, on 2 Apr 1637.31 Jonathan died in Plymouth, MA on 19 May 1708.63 “Left Jonathan Mory Deceased May 19^th 1708 being Entered into the 75 yer of his age”.

On 23 Dec 1656 Sarah married Samuel Rider, son of Samuel Rider & Anne Gamlett (-14 Dec 1695), in Plymouth, MA.62 Born ca 1630.298 Samuel was baptized in All Saints Parish, Northampton, on 25 Nov 1632.31 Samuel died in Plymouth, MA on 18 Jul 1715.63 Occupation: cooper.

Samuel, of Yarmouth.

Ca 1663 Joseph married Hannah Pope, daughter of Thomas Pope (ca 1612-1683) & Anne Fallowell (ca 1616-bef May 1646), in Plymouth, MA.16 Born ca 1639 in Plymouth, MA.188 Hannah died in Plymouth, MA 12 Mar 1709/10.63

On 26 Dec 1661 Elizabeth married Anthony Sprague (10580) , son of William Sprague (4317) (ca 1611-26 Oct 1675) & Millicent Eames (3515) (ca 1617-8 Feb 1695/6), in Plymouth, MA.62 Born on 2 Sep 1635 in Charlestown, MA.379 Anthony was baptized in Charlestown, MA, on 23 May 1636.298 Anthony died in Hingham, MA, on 3 Dec 1719; he was 84.298 Occupation: Farmer.

Anthony, of Hingham. His house, along with five others, was burned 20 Apr 1676 by the Indians in Philip’s war.25 He was selctman in 1688, 1692, and 1700, resided on paternal homestead, Hingham Center.379

Ca 1670 Lydia first married James Barnaby.16 James died bef 30 Oct 1677.188

Ca 1678 Lydia second married John Nelson, son of William Nelson (ca 1615-15 Dec 1679) & Martha Ford (ca 1619-20 Dec 1683). Born on 8 Jun 1647 in Middleborough, MA. John died in Plymouth, MA, on 29 Apr 1697; he was 49.63 “John Nelson deceased on the 29^th of Aprill 1697, being Entred into the 54^th yeare of His age”.

John was one of the propietors of Middleborough.

On 25 Dec 1668 when Mercy was 17, she married John Joy, son of Thomas Joy (ca 1611-21 Oct 1678) & Joan Gallop (ca 1618-12 Mar 1690/1), in Plymouth, MA.16,62 Born on 10 Oct 1641 in Boston, MA.45 John died in Boston, MA bef 1678.

John, of Boston. (Joy, not Ivey).16

John may have been the one born 10 Oct 1641 in Boston, the son of Thomas and Joan (Gallop) Joy, and if so, he died before Thomas Joy wrote his will 8 Jul 1677.188