On 5 Jul 1750 Abigail first married Joseph Hitchcock (33897) , son of Ebenezer Hitchcock (17065) (9 Apr 1689-ca 1727) & Anna Perkins (16072) (5 Nov 1690-Nov 1757), in New Haven, CT.56 Born ca 1726 in New Haven, CT. Joseph was baptized in First Congregational Society, New Haven, on 3 Apr 1726.55 Joseph died in New Haven, CT on 19 Jul 1773.56

Joseph “was born earlier than 1717 for he is called Jospeh, Sr., on the New Haven records. Those records also seem to show that Joseph lived at one time in Bethany; ‘April 24, 1771, Jospeh Hitchcock of New Haven society of Bethany to Ebenezer Hitchcock of New Haven society of Mt. Carmel piece of land which was laid out to Ebenezer of New Haven.’ ... His widow Abigail administered on his estate in Oct., 1774.”409

On 16 Jul 1776 Abigail second married Capt. James Peck (24674) , son of James Peck (17 Feb 1679-1760) & Abigail Morris (9566) (22 Aug 1683-bef 1729), in Congregational Society, Woodbridge.55 Born on 4 Aug 1708 in New Haven, CT.56 James died in New Haven, CT, on 2 Mar 1794; he was 85.55 Buried in City Burial Ground, New Haven.