On 24 May 1705 when Nathan was 26, he first married
Sarah Arey, daughter of
Richard Arey (ca 1640-14 Feb 1689) &
Sarah Marchant (ca 1661/2-Jan 1729), in Wellfleet, MA.
Born ca 1684 in Edgartown, Dukes County, Massachusetts. Sarah died in Falmouth, MA on 14 Mar 1734.