On 8 Nov 1763 when Joseph was 42, he second married
Thankful Vinal (58725) , daughter of
John Vinal (48484) (Sep 1705-) &
Sarah Cudworth (47517) (12 Sep 1708-), in First Parish Church of Scituate.
52 Born ca 1734 in Scituate, MA. Thankful was baptized in First Parish Church of Scituate, on 20 Oct 1734.625 Thankful died in Scituate, MA in 1806.52
Thankful, dau. of John Vinal (son of Jacob). Joseph and Thankful were second cousins; their paternal grandfathers were brothers.