On 10 Dec 1730 when Martha was 15, she married Capt. Ichabod Phelps (21805) , son of Joseph Phelps (8097) (27 Sep 1666-30 Aug 1716) & Sarah Hosford (27 Sep 1666-), in Hebron, CT.331 Born on 3 Apr 1708 in Windsor, CT.115 Ichabod died in Hebron, CT, on 5 Jan 1794; he was 85. Buried in Gilead Cemetery, Hebron.

From The Phelps Family of America:116
    (#168) Capt. Ichabod Phelps, b. Windsor, Ct., 3 April, 1708, m. 10 Dec, 1730, Martha Tillotson, b. 1715, d. Hebron, Ct., 3 Feb., 1786. aged 71 years. He m. 2nd widow Hubbell of Bolton; by her he had no issue.
    Mr. Phelps settled in that part of Hebron known as Gilead Hill, and about twenty rods south of the Gilead meetinghouse. He served in the Revolutionary war in Capt. Skinner’s Co. as sergeant, enlisting Aug. 25, discharged Nov. 8, 1777. He also served in the war of 1755, as captain in Col. Quartus’s company. Frequent reference is made to Captain Ichabod Phelps in manuscript records in State Library, Albany, N. Y., in war of 1755.
    Children, b. Hebron, Ct., by 1st wife:
    i. Martha, b. 23 Sept., 1732, m. Rev. Dr, Trumbull.
    ii. Ichabod, b. 24 Jan., 1735, d. 14 Aug., 1736.
    iii. Abiah, b. 21 Feb., 1736-7, m. John Talcott.
    iv. Ichabod, b. 11 Feb., 1738, m. Mary Trumbull.
    v. Abitha, b. 8 Feb., bpt. 19, 1740, m. Thomas Post.
    vi. Azubah, b. 30 Oct., 1745, d. 26 Dec, 1745.
    vii. Azelphia, b. 30 Oct., 1745, m. Dea. Asaph Trumbull.
    viii. Daniel, b. 4 Oct., 1747, d. Oct. 3, 1753, age 6.
    ix. Azubah, b. 7 July, 1752, m. Zeo Case.
    x. Anna, b. 20 Feb., 1755, m. Daniel Brown.

On 5 Jun 1739 when Deborah was 19, she married Nathaniel Mann (49044) , son of Nathaniel Mann (31873) (27 Oct 1693-21 Oct 1758) & Mary Root (24 Nov 1689-19 May 1728), in Hebron, CT.331 Born 16 Jan 1715/6 in Hebron, CT.331

On 16 Sep 1742 when Daniel was 21, he married Mindwell Hosford, daughter of Obadiah Hosford (23 Sep 1677-27 Feb 1740) & Mindwell Phelps (ca 1682-3 Oct 1771), in Hebron, CT.331 Born on 20 May 1722 in Hebron, CT.331 Mindwell died in Orford, Grafton County, New Hampshire, on 31 Mar 1807; she was 84.