On 10 Dec 1730 when Ichabod was 22, he first married
Martha Tillotson (38348) , daughter of
Capt. Morris Tillotson (25 Oct 1683-18 Feb 1761) &
Martha Phelps (19060) (29 Oct 1690-25 Jul 1776), in Hebron, CT.
331 Born on 16 May 1715 in Hebron, CT.331 Martha died in Hebron, CT, on 3 Feb 1786; she was 70.331 Buried in Gilead Cemetery, Hebron.
Ichabod and Martha were first cousins once removed; his father and her maternal grandfather were brothers.