In 1802 Lyman married Miriam Dayton (54423) , daughter of Capt. Jonathan Dayton (38223) (31 Jan 1726/7-31 Jul 1804) & Bede Cooper (54437) (16 Jun 1757-3 Mar 1822), in Wallingford, CT.488 Born in Jan 1785 in North Haven, CT.55 Miriam died in Hamden, CT on 9 Jul 1862.55 Buried in Old Graveyard, Mount Carmel, Hamden.

Children of Lyman and Miriam (Dayton) Tuttle, born at Hamden:
    i. Abuid Tuttle;
    ii. Adelia Tuttle;
    iii. Milo Tuttle;
    iv. Beclostia (or Bedotha) Tuttle;
    v. Lyman Tuttle;
    vi. Meriam Tuttle;
    vii. Celestia Tuttle;
    viii. Sally Tuttle;
    ix. Dayton Tuttle;
    x. Darling Tuttle;
    xi. Starling Tuttle, twin; ane
    xii. Laura A. Tuttle.488