Between 1662 And 1670 Joseph first married Elizabeth.517 Elizabeth died in Hadley, Hampshire County, Massachusetts between 9 Mar 1675/6 and 22 Mar 1677/8.517

Joseph, Mary, and James may have been Elizabeth’s children, or they may be the children of an earlier wife of Joseph if Elizabeth was not his first wife.517

Between 9 Mar 1675/6 And 22 Mar 1677/8 Joseph second married Sarah Coley (14340) , daughter of Samuel Coley (ca 1614-17 Aug 1684) & Ann Prudden (4988) (ca 1617/8-3 Oct 1689). Born ca 1648 in Milford, CT. Sarah was baptized in Milford, CT, on 24 Sep 1648.64 Sarah died in Springfield, Hampden County, Massachusetts on 30 Sep 1689.517

Benjamin married Hannah Sargeant.

Hannah Sargeant of Branford.

On 6 May 1658 Hannah married Jeremiah Hull (2734) , son of Richard Hull (1202) (3 Dec 1599-ca 1 Sep 1662) & Dorothy Hiner, in Milford, CT.56 Born ca 1640/1645 in New Haven, CT. Jeremiah died in New Haven, CT on 13 Jun 1700.56

On 23 Sep 1662 Mary married John Catlin, son of John Catlin (ca 1617-bef 17 Jul 1655) & Isabel Ward (ca 1625-8 Dec 1676), in Wethersfield, CT.161 Born on 28 Jun 1643 in Wethersfield, CT. John died in Deerfield, Franklin County, Massachusetts, on 29 Feb 1704; he was 60.

From the History of Deerfield, genealogy pages 104–105:161
        John was of Wethersfield, 1662; of Branford, 1665, whence he removed to Newark, where he was a teacher 1676; in 1678 he was “Town’s Attorney (not lawyer), an ‘honest brother,’ to take care that all town orders be executed, and if a breach occurs to punish the offender;” selectman 1676–81; was of Hartford 1683, of Deerfield. soon after, as one of the early permanent settlers, where he was dignified by the title of “Mr.” and took a prominent part in affairs; no family suffered more than his at the desolation of the town 1704; his buildings were all burned, and himself and son Jonathan consumed with them; one son was killed in the Meadow fight; another and three daughters were captured, and two of the latter killed on the march.

On 31 Mar 1664 Elizabeth married Dea. James Warriner, son of William Warriner (-2 Jun 1676) & Joanna (-7 Feb 1661), in Hadley, Hampshire County, Massachusetts.64 Born on 21 Nov 1640 in Springfield, Hampden County, Massachusetts.455 James died in Springfield, Hampden County, Massachusetts, on 14 May 1727; he was 86.455

On 26 Dec 1667 Martha married John Hawkes, son of John Hawkes (ca 1618-Jul 1662) & Elizabeth Brown (ca 1620-29 Sep 1685).151 Born ca 1643 in Windsor, CT. John was baptized on 13 Aug 1643.151

On 2 Nov 1677 when Jonathan was 28, he first married Hannah Ward, daughter of John Ward, in Milford, CT.65 Hannah died in Milford, CT on 9 Jun 1693.65

Children of Jonathan and Hannah (Ward) Baldwin, born at Milford:
    i. Jonathan Baldwin, b. 31 Jan 1679/80, m. at Milford 28 Sep 1710 Mary Tibblas, removed to Waterbury, CT;
    ii. John Baldwin, b. 22 May 1683, d. 20 Jan 1773, bur. at Conn. Farms, NJ;
    iii. Joseph Baldwin, bp. 29 Nov 1685 d. 20 Sep 1777, resided at Newark, NJ;
    iv. Hannah Baldwin, d. young;
    v. Daniel Baldwin, bp. 3 Mar 1688/9; and
    vi. Joshua Baldwin, bp. 24 Jan 1691.65

Jonathan second married Thankful Strong (10816) , daughter of Eld. John Strong (ca 1610-14 Apr 1699) & Abigail Ford (3606) (ca 1619-6 Jul 1688). Born on 25 Jul 1663 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts.115 Thankful died in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts, on 24 May 1754; she was 90.

Children of Jonathan and Thankful (Strong) Baldwin, born at Milford:
    i. Abigail Baldwin, bp. 1695, m. Joseph Tibbals (b. ca. Mar 1687/8 at Milford, d. 14 Oct 1774, settled at Durham, CT;
    ii. Hannah Baldwin, bp. 1696, d. 10 Dec 1776, bur. at Northford, CT, m. 6 Jan 1723 Josiah Fowler (b. ca. 1688 at Guilfod, d. 7 Sep 1757, son of Abraham & Elizabeth (Bartlett) Fowler);
    iii. Martha Baldwin, bp. 1698, d. soon;
    iv. Ebenezer Baldwin, b. 1699, d. bef. 1728;
    v. Noah Baldwin, bp. 30 Nov 1701, d. 3 Mar 1784 at Milford, m. there 27 Mar 1733 Thankful Johnson of Stratford (d.6 Feb 1802 at Milford);
    vi. Phebe Baldwin, b. 6 Nov 1704, unmarried in 1728; and
    vii. Ezra Baldwin, b. 1 Dec 1706, bp. 3 Dec 1706, d. 26 Mar 1782 at Durham, m. there 2 Dec 1728 Ruth Curtis (d. 2 Nov 1772 at Durham).

On 11 Nov 1674 David married Mary Stream, daughter of Ens. John Stream (-1685) & Martha Beard (-22 Jun 1706), in Milford, CT.65 Born on 12 Oct 1653 in Milford, CT.65 Mary died in Milford, CT, on 28 May 1712; she was 58.65

Bef 21 May 1676 Sarah married Samuel Bartlett, son of Robert Bartlett (ca 1612-16 Mar 1675/6) & Anne (-3 Jul 1676).16 Born ca 1640 in Hartford, CT.16 Samuel died in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts on 21 Feb 1712.

Samuel, of Northampton, MA. He first married Mary Bridgeman, second Sarah Baldwin.