On 11 Dec 1814 Valentine Wightman first married Roxana Smith, daughter of Joseph Smith (19 Jan 1773-30 Jul 1845) & Hannah Slater (Feb 1775-21 Oct 1857), in Sempronius, Cayuga County, New York. Born on 11 Apr 1795 in Killingly, CT. Roxana died in Scott Township, Steuben County, Indiana, on 28 Aug 1858; she was 63.389

On 30 Jun 1859 Valentine Wightman second married Mary Bell Hamilton.389 Born on 6 Dec 1837.389

On 18 Oct 1818 Bradley Rose married Achsah Hubbell, daughter of Shadrach Hubbell (18 Feb 1771-28 May 1829) & Asenath Moore.389 Born on 13 Aug 1797. Achsah died in Barton, Tioga County, New York, on 25 Jul 1839; she was 41.

After Bradley died and Achsah married her second husband, David B. Durrie, her new husband refused to care for her three children. All were sent out to service: Charles in Cayuga Co., William in Seneca Co., NY, and Candace M. in Nunda., NY.389

Ca 1816 Achsah married Luke Kilmore, son of Heinrich Kilmer (14 Mar 1768-1820) & Catherine Witbeck. Born on 8 Jul 1793 in Sempronius, Cayuga County, New York. Luke died in Salina, Onondaga County, New York, on 20 Apr 1857; he was 63.

History of the Kilmer Family in America, edited by Charles H. Kilmer. Page 88.
Children of Luke 3 [Henry 2, Heinrich 1.]
CATHERINE. Maried Ezra Cowner of Syracuse, NY
DANIEL BRADLEY. Married Miss Marguerita Matty. Her father was a cousin of Marshall B. Soult, one of Napoleon’s grand marshalls.
    Daniel was captain of a packet from Syracuse to Buffalo. In 1863 he became ticket agent for the Michigan Central RR. After this kept a wood yard seven years. Accumulated enough resources to live a retired life, and died in 1887.
SCHUYLER V. Married Miss Mary Matty, a sister of his brother Daniel B.’s wife.
    He has been captain of a packet boat, seven years traveling ticket agent for the Michigan Souther RR, and twenty years superintendent of the American Dairy Salt Company. Residence, 220 Seymour street, Syracuse, NY.
CORWIN. Died 1849 and no family.
VERNUM.Married Amelia Wright. Went to sea in 1845. After leaving sea life went to California. Returned to Syracuse, NY, and was employed by the New York Central RR, which position he retained twenty years. Then went to state of Washington.
KATURAH. Married Enos Fields. He is dea, and she is living at Waterloo, NY.
LUKE. Married either a Gilman or Gilmore. He was a sea captain. His family are supposed to be in Australia.
DELOSS. In state of Washington.
ROSELTHA. Married George Bragdon.
JAQUELINA. Married Hiram Seeley. He is dead. She at Little Falls NY.

1840; Census Place: Salina, Onondaga County, New York census; Roll: 316; Page: 26; Image: 57; Family History Library Film: 0017200.
Males
5-9 2
10-14 1
15-19 2
20-29 3
40-49 1
Females
Under 5 3
10-14 1
20-29 1
40-49 1
Persons employed in Navigation of Canals, Lakes, Rivers - 3

1850 Syracuse Ward 3, Onondaga County, New York census; Roll: M432_569;  Dwelling 2095; Family 2214; Page: 156B; Image: 317.
Luke is 56, Axy is 58, Dann is 32, Demus is 17, Bradley is 15, Rosetha is 13, and Jackalam is 10. Everyone was born in New York. Luke has $1000 in real estate. Reading occupations is almost impossible.

1855 New York State Census. Syracuse City, Ward 5; Household 3; Line 13; Sheet 1; Ancestry.com. New York, State Census, 1855 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2013.
Luke is 60, Achsa is 57, Deloss is 22, Jaqualina is 15. Rasselus is 20 and his wife Cathrin is 17.
Luke was born in Columbia County, NY. Achsa was born in Vermont. Luke and Achsa have both lived in Syracuse for 30 years. Deloss was born in Jefferson County, NY and has lived in Syracuse for 20 years. Everyone else was born in Onondaga County. Luke and Rasselus are farmers and Deloss is a laborer.

Nancy married Anthony Smith. Anthony died in Niles, Cayuga County, New York.

On 27 Jan 1822 when Joshua was 20, he married Penelope Cutler (65166) , daughter of Bradley Cutler (29 Aug 1776-12 May 1863) & Sabra Wade (60822) (28 Mar 1773-17 Sep 1863), in Sempronius, Cayuga County, New York. Born on 30 Sep 1804 in Richfield, Otsego County, New York. Penelope died on 4 Aug 1876; she was 71.

Penelope Cutler, born 30 Sept. 1804 in Otsego, Herkiner Co., New York. She married Joshua Rothone [Rathbone}. He was born 1800 Otsego, Herkiner Co., New York. Penelope died 4 Aug 1876. The Descendants of Col. Jonathan Wade and Some of His Descendents Who Settled in Rhode Island, A Speical Report for the Rhode Island Historical Society, 3 May 1999, by Charles, V. Waid. Parts I and II, page 14.

ATWATER CEMETERY was later known as Reynolds Cemetery and Skilton has "Sempronius Cemetery - not far from the Church"

Located in the NW corner of Lot No. 89, 3/4 mile from Sempronius hamlet and church, on south side of Frazier Road, as shown on page 65, New Century Atlas of Cayuga Co., NY. Copied 1959 by Leslie Luther, Moravia, NY.

Atwater or Sempronius Cemtery Records http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem186.htm “This cemetery is horribly overgrown, the back part almost impassable with bushes and briars. Here again I found stones down so long they were entirely covered with a mat of myrtle, which went unnoticed unless you just happened to walk there and feel a firmness underfoot.

The Skilton records contained 27 names, L. Luther has 44, and I found 52. By doing this composite list of these three, we have about 80 names. And I am sure there must still be some we didn't happen to walk on. Copied 1962 by Mabel Crosby, Moravia, RD #1
This cemetery has the following Cutlers:
Cutler, Bradley d. May 12, 1863 ae 87y
Cutler, Sabra his wife d. Sep.17, 1863 ae 90y
Cutler, Nathan d. Jul.8, 1875 ae 75y
Cutler, Ruth Whiting, w of Nathan d. May 7, 1874 ae
Cutler, Alvira w of Myron D. Cutler d. Oct.25, 1854 ae 29-5-1

Sand Hill Cemetery, Town of Sempronius, Located 8 1/2 miles north of Dresserville, on west side of road toward Kelloggsville. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem185.htmCopied 1955 by Leslie L. Luther. This cemetery has these Cutlers:

Cutler, Charles W. b. Jan. 21, 1828 d. Aug. 16, 1900
    Sarah M., his wife b. June 12, 1830 d. Apr. 23, 1897
    Elmer b. Jan. 6, 1870 d. Apr. 11, 1910
Cutler, William 1863-1927
Cutler, Hattie M. 1851-1936

INDIAN MOUND CEMETERY, Moravia, New York, Transcribed by Steve and Pat McKay
CUTLER, http://members.aol.com/gendata54/imound.html#CHenry, b Aug. 27, 1792 d Mar. 18, 1866. This cemetery has the following Cutlers and related families:
CUTLER, Henry, b Aug. 27, 1792 d Mar. 18, 1866
    Mercy BISHOP his wife, b Apr. 5, 1796 d Mar. 31, 1854
    M. A., ____ - ____
    McClean, Susan, b Mar. 12, 179(3?) d Sept. 30, 1835
CUTLER, Henry, 1822 - 1899
    Emily McClean, 1829 - 1913
    Willard, 1848 - 1934
    Jennie VAN ETTEN, 1849 - 1929
    MINER, Charles T., 1876 - 1943
    Alice CUTLER, 1874 - 1946
Cutler, Rhoda M., dau of John & Wealthy d. Mar. 29, 1876 ae 58y 10mo
Cutler, "Little Johnny" d. ae 14months
Smith, Dorr 1840-1916
    Thalia F. Cutler, his wife 1841-1916
CHRUCH, Byron, 1841 - 1900, (F. & A.M. emblem), "Father"
    Carrie K. his wife, 1844-1929, "Mother"
    William R. their son, 1870 - 1900, "Will"
    CUTLER, Fay, 1857 - 1931, "Fay"
    Anna M. his wife, 1858 - 1929, "Anna"
    Infant son, -1899-
MELLEN, Jeremiah d Oct. 21, 1881 ae 78 yrs, "Father"
    "An honest man, God's noblest work."The tribute of a Son.
    Fanny wife of J. MELLEN d Aug. 7, 1877 ae 73 yrs, "Mother"
    Adelphia wife of Allen PORTER, 1836 - 1870, "Adelphia"
    Melita wife of James B. HUNTER, d July 22, 1871 ae 28 yrs, "Melita"
    J. Knowlton, 1838 - 1912, "Knowlton"
    Proctor, d in Hampton Hospital, Fortress Monroe, d June 22, 1865 ae 24 yrs, "Proctor"
    "Our Alice" went home Dec. 22, 1861 ae 16 yrs, "Alice"
    Dwight d Oct. 27, 1856 ae 30 yrs, "Our first born and God's"
    CUTLER, Janette MELLEN, d July 17, 1865 ae 34 yrs
    (Note: In 1955, a headstone was found near the tool house face down with inscription:
    "Janet, wife of J.L. CUTLER, M.D., died July 17, 1865 ae 34y 8mo, 26da")
    Also on this lot a headstone: "Martha" and a large iron dog

Kelloggsville Cemetery, Town of Sempronius. This cemetery is located in the NW corner of Lot 47, town of Sempronius, Cayuga Co., NY, a short distance S of Kelloggsville hamlet, on the W side of the road to Dresserville, as indicated on the map of Niles township, New Century Atlas of Cay. Co., NY, 1904. Copied by L. Luther - 1959. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem189.htm
The Kelloggsville Cemetery has these Cutlers:
Cutler, Frank H. 1855-1917
    Carrie H., his w 1860-1948
    D. K. 1882-1940
    Jennie M., his wife 1883-1972
    M. Aleeta 1917-1919
    Margaret C. Lieber 1908-1951

A History & Profile of the Town of Mentz, Village of Port Byron & Hamlet of Centerport
Cayuga County, New York As contained in the book: History of Cayuga County, New York 1789-1879; By Elliot G. Storke, Chapter XXXVII. “The successive presidents are Elmore P. Ross, 1838; Samuel Harnden, 1839, `42 and `43; Cyrus C. Peas, 1840 and `41; James CUTLER, 1844, `45 and `47-`51 . . . “

God’s Acre Cemetery, South Seneca ST., Weedsport, N.Y. NOTE: Names marked with an asterick (*) are from a list made by Raymond B. Traver in 1916 but which could not be authenticated. http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/cem/cem24.htm. It lists only:
CUTLER, William *, d. 1848

TOWN OF MORAVIA MORAVIA RURAL or DRY CREEK CEMETERY
Located on the southern edge of the Village of Moravia, Route 38, back in on the east side of the road. Copied by Leslie L. Luther, Moravia, NY. It lists:
CUTLER Alice d. Mar. 31, 1854 b. July 21, 1830
    dau. of H. & E.A.
    Edward d. Sept. 22, 1852 b. Apr. 27, 1832
    son of H. & E.A.

Complete Name Index to The History of Cayuga County 1789-1879 book by Elliot Storke index by Leslie Luther transcription by Elaine Hutson http://www.rootsweb.com/~nycayuga/storke/a.html
Lists the following:
CUTLER A. H. 446
Bradley 483
Charles 481
Henry 77, 459, 461, 474

Keturah married Varnum Potter.