On 22 Jan 1829 when Sarah Louisa was 23, she married
Henry Butt, son of
Benjamin Butt (ca 1770-2 Jun 1828) &
Catherine Elizabeth Dietzel (28 Dec 1770-5 Jul 1841), in Canfield, Mahoning County, Ohio.
680 Married by Billings O. Plimpton, MG.
Born ca 1802 in Tyrone, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. Henry died in Canfield, Mahoning County, Ohio on 11 Dec 1869. Buried in Canfield Village Cemetery.
Henry’s father had arrived in Canfield by the 1820 Census.
1830 Federal Census. Canfield, Trumbull County, Ohio
Roll 141, page 259
Family of Henry Butts
1 male 20-29 [Henry]
1 female 20-29 [Sarah]
1840 Federal Census. Canfield, Trumbull County, Ohio
Roll 429, page 208
Family of Henry Butt
1 male under 5 [Cornelius, 4]
1 male 20-29 [?]
1 male 30-39 [Henry, 38]
1 female 5-9 [Mary, 8]
1 female 30-39 [Sarah, 35]
Note, the southern part of Trumbull County, including Canfield, split off to become Mahoning county in 1846.
1850 Federal Census. Canfield, Mahoning County, Ohio
Roll 707, page 489
Henry Butt, 47, carpenter, $450 real estate, b. PA
Sarah L. Butt, 42, b. NY
Mary L. Butt, 18, b. OH
Cornelius Butt, 14, b. OH
Wallace Brainard, 1, b. OH
John Wallace Brainerd was the baby son of Fredrick Brainerd and his late wife Minervia (Twiss) Brainerd. Apparently the Brainerd family was well known to the Hitchcocks. Sarah’s nephew Noble Merwin later married Fredrick Brainerd’s neice Helen Brainerd.
1860 Federal Census. Canfield, Mahoning County, Ohio
Roll 1005, page 272
Post Office Canfield
Henry Butt, 58, carpenter, $1500 real estate, $100 personal estate, b. PA
Sarah L. Butt, 54, b. NY
Mary L. Butt, 28, b. OH
Cornelius Butt, 24, b. OH
The Mohoning Vindicator of Youngstown, Mahoning County, Ohio lists in its 17 December 1869 issue the death of Henry Butt of Canfield on 11 December 1869 of consumption. He was 60 years of age.